| Date | Player | Milestones | |
| 04-01-2017 | David Crumb | 250 Wins, while playing for Pittsburgh | |
| 04-03-2017 | Mario Beauvais | 300 Home Runs, while playing for Tintagel | |
| 04-11-2017 | Armando Silva | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Baltimore | |
| 04-16-2017 | Alex Talley | 2000 Hits, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 04-25-2017 | William Slama | 1500 Runs Batted In, while playing for Louisville | |
| 05-21-2017 | Douglas Ridings | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Pittsburgh | |
| 06-05-2017 | Wilton Schroder | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Las Vegas | |
| 06-07-2017 | Man Kummer | 2000 Hits, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 07-13-2017 | William Slama | 1500 Runs Scored, while playing for Louisville | |
| 08-17-2017 | Mario Beauvais | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Tintagel | |
| 08-21-2017 | Mario Beauvais | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Tintagel | |
| 08-30-2017 | Ralph Mancilla | 2000 Hits, while playing for Las Vegas | |
| 09-06-2017 | Michael Kephart | 400 Home Runs, while playing for Maui | |
| 09-10-2017 | Laurence Roberts | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 09-15-2017 | Tyree Solano | 300 Home Runs, while playing for Ocean City | |
| 09-29-2017 | Michael Kephart | 1500 Runs Batted In, while playing for Maui | |
| 04-02-2018 | George Vela | 300 Home Runs, while playing for Vancouver | |
| 04-18-2018 | Thomas Slade | 2000 Hits, while playing for Gotham | |
| 05-22-2018 | Faustino Plyler | 1500 Runs Batted In, while playing for Louisville | |
| 06-13-2018 | Michael DePalma | 300 Wins, while playing for Louisville | |
| 06-28-2018 | Man Kummer | 400 Home Runs, while playing for Baltimore | |
| 07-16-2018 | Ralph Mancilla | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 08-02-2018 | Richard McClay | 2500 Hits, while playing for Maui | |
| 08-07-2018 | George Vela | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Vancouver | |
| 08-13-2018 | Leandro Howe | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Tennessee | |
| 08-14-2018 | Douglas Ridings | 2000 Hits, while playing for Memphis | |
| 09-05-2018 | Ron Christopher | 2000 Hits, while playing for Ocean City | |
| 09-25-2018 | Michael Merlino | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Louisville | |
| 09-29-2018 | Wilton Schroder | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Bradford | |
| 04-08-2019 | Richard Broadnax | 1500 Runs Batted In, while playing for Miami | |
| 04-12-2019 | Thomas Slade | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Gotham | |
| 05-02-2019 | Glen Brewer | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Ocean City | |
| 05-03-2019 | Chad Strickland | 3000 Strikeouts, while playing for Gotham | |
| 05-23-2019 | Alex Talley | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 05-28-2019 | Jed Elsea | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Gotham | |
| 06-08-2019 | Armando Silva | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Baltimore | |
| 06-15-2019 | John Denn | 2500 Hits, while playing for San Francisco | |
| 06-17-2019 | Edward Parker | 2000 Hits, while playing for Tennessee | |
| 06-19-2019 | Glen Brewer | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Ocean City | |
| 06-19-2019 | Richard Broadnax | 500 Home Runs, while playing for Miami | |
| 06-28-2019 | Ronald Pohl | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Louisville | |
| 07-02-2019 | Ronald Pohl | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Louisville | |
| 07-23-2019 | Ushigorou Tetsuhiko | 300 Home Runs, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 07-24-2019 | Steven Chambers | 2000 Hits, while playing for Gotham | |
| 07-26-2019 | David Swint | 2000 Hits, while playing for Pittsburgh | |
| 07-27-2019 | Richard Broadnax | 2000 Hits, while playing for Miami | |
| 08-13-2019 | Benny Ramirez | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Phoenix | |
| 08-16-2019 | Benny Ramirez | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Phoenix | |
| 08-16-2019 | Ushigorou Tetsuhiko | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 08-21-2019 | John Mohammad | 1000 Runs Scored, while playing for Maui | |
| 08-23-2019 | Darrell Woodall | 200 Wins, while playing for Maui | |
| 08-27-2019 | Zachary Roca | 2000 Hits, while playing for Cooperstown | |
| 09-04-2019 | Michael Merlino | 1000 Runs Batted In, while playing for Louisville | |
| 09-13-2019 | Michael Kephart | 3000 Hits, while playing for Maui | |
| 09-21-2019 | Benny Ramirez | 2000 Hits, while playing for Phoenix | |